There is No Legal Authority for Commercial Fish Farming in Great Lakes Waters

shareShare on FacebookTweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInPin on Pinterest

The Great Lakes are not and cannot be a “gold mine” for any private person or corporation. They are owned by the State in public trust for each citizen. The Supreme Courts of Michigan, the U.S. and other states have ruled for more than 120 years that public trust bottomlands and waters cannot be transferred or occupied or subordinated for primarily private gain. Not the DEQ, not private interests, not the Governor, not the legislature, not even the courts can violate this principle. Moreover, given the environmental effects and the fact that feasible and prudent on-land alternatives exist, fish farming the Great Lakes would violate basic environmental law standards. So it’s time for the fish farming industry to stop promising “gold mines” for the Great Lakes.  They are not legal, they cannot be approved.  Land is for farms, the Great Lakes are for navigation, fishing, swimming, drinking water, sustenance, and recreation, aquatic life, and our own quality of life. There is no authority for private development of aquaculture CAFOs or any water farms in the Great Lakes, so the debate over environmental impacts is a waste of time. Moreover, because there are on-land alternatives, they must be done or shown to be totally unfeasible and not prudent. If anything, on-land fish farming is feasible and prudent.

One comment on “There is No Legal Authority for Commercial Fish Farming in Great Lakes Waters

  1. Christian A Guest on

    I wonder…I keep hearing of Canadian-run pen-rearing of fish on Lake Huron. Is Canada not bound by the same legal restraints.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *